Understanding the Difference Between Dismissive Avoidant and Fearful Avoidant Attachment Styles

Understanding the Difference Between Dismissive Avoidant and Fearful Avoidant Attachment Styles

Attachment theory, developed by psychologist John Bowlby, explains how early relationships with caregivers shape the way we form and maintain relationships throughout our lives. One of the most important aspects of this theory is the concept of attachment styles—patterns of how we interact with others emotionally. Two attachment styles that can often be confused but have distinct characteristics are Dismissive Avoidant and Fearful Avoidant.

While both types share a tendency to avoid emotional closeness, their motivations and behaviors differ significantly. Let’s dive into the key differences between these two avoidant attachment styles.

‍

What is Avoidant Attachment?

Before exploring the distinctions between Dismissive Avoidant and Fearful Avoidant attachment, it’s helpful to understand the general characteristics of avoidant attachment.

Individuals with avoidant attachment tend to suppress their emotions and avoid close relationships because they fear vulnerability or perceive dependence as a weakness. Avoidant individuals often prioritize independence and may have difficulty trusting others. However, within the avoidant category, there are two subtypes: Dismissive Avoidant and Fearful Avoidant.

‍

Dismissive Avoidant Attachment

Dismissive Avoidant individuals are often highly independent and self-sufficient. They have a tendency to downplay the importance of relationships and emotional connections. These individuals might seem distant or emotionally unavailable, but this is typically a defense mechanism rather than an indication of a lack of desire for intimacy.

Key Characteristics of Dismissive Avoidant Attachment:

• High Value on Independence: They prioritize their autonomy and often reject emotional dependence on others. They may feel uncomfortable or even threatened by others' emotional needs.
• Suppression of Emotions: Dismissive Avoidants may appear emotionally detached or distant. They tend to suppress or deny their feelings, even in relationships.
• Positive Self-Image, Negative View of Others: People with this attachment style typically have a positive view of themselves but may view others as unreliable or untrustworthy.
• Difficulty with Intimacy: While they can maintain relationships, they struggle to form deep emotional connections or to allow vulnerability.
• Avoidance of Conflict: They may avoid confronting difficult emotions or relationship issues, often shutting down rather than addressing problems directly.

Dismissive Avoidant individuals often learned in childhood that their emotional needs wouldn’t be met, leading them to become self-reliant. As adults, they may value their space and may struggle to see the need for emotional closeness or intimacy in their relationships.

‍

Fearful Avoidant Attachment

Fearful Avoidant individuals, on the other hand, experience a more complex and conflicting emotional response when it comes to relationships. They crave closeness and intimacy but are simultaneously afraid of it due to past experiences of trauma or rejection. This internal conflict can lead to erratic behaviors in relationships, such as seeking closeness and then pulling away when they feel too vulnerable.

Key Characteristics of Fearful Avoidant Attachment:

• Desire for Intimacy, But Fear of It: Fearful Avoidants long for deep emotional connections but often fear being hurt or rejected. Their fear of getting too close to others causes them to push people away.
• Low Self-Esteem and Negative View of Others: Unlike Dismissive Avoidants, who have a positive self-image, Fearful Avoidants often struggle with low self-worth. They may have a negative view of both themselves and others.
• Emotional Turmoil: Fearful Avoidants experience a great deal of inner conflict. They may want closeness but then feel overwhelmed by the fear of rejection, resulting in emotional highs and lows within relationships.
• Difficulty Trusting Others: Due to past trauma or inconsistent caregiving in childhood, Fearful Avoidants often have a hard time trusting others, which can make them anxious in relationships.
• Self-Sabotage in Relationships: The fear of being hurt can lead them to sabotage relationships by withdrawing or pushing their partner away, even if they still care deeply.

Fearful Avoidants may have experienced inconsistent caregiving in childhood, where their caregivers were sometimes nurturing and sometimes neglectful or abusive. As a result, they are conflicted about relationships—wanting closeness, but fearing it will lead to pain or abandonment.

‍

Key Differences Between Dismissive Avoidant and Fearful Avoidant

1. Motivation for Avoidance:
   
   
   • Dismissive Avoidant: They avoid closeness because they value independence and see emotional dependence as a weakness. They might not actively seek intimacy, believing they don’t need it.
   • Fearful Avoidant: They avoid closeness because they fear being hurt or rejected. They want emotional intimacy but are conflicted by the fear that it will lead to pain.
2. Emotional Regulation:
   
   
   • Dismissive Avoidant: Dismissive Avoidants are generally better at suppressing or numbing their emotions. They keep a tight lid on their feelings and may not even recognize or process their emotional needs.
   • Fearful Avoidant: Fearful Avoidants are often overwhelmed by their emotions. They experience intense emotional highs and lows, and this emotional turmoil can make it difficult to maintain stable relationships.
3. Perception of Self and Others:
   
   
   • Dismissive Avoidant: They tend to have a positive view of themselves but a negative view of others. They may see others as needy or unreliable and feel they are better off on their own.
   • Fearful Avoidant: Fearful Avoidants have a negative view of both themselves and others. They may feel unworthy of love and fear that others will reject or abandon them.
4. Approach to Relationships:
   
   
   • Dismissive Avoidant: These individuals often disengage from relationships, maintaining emotional distance. They tend to keep others at arm’s length and might struggle to form deep, lasting bonds.
   • Fearful Avoidant: Fearful Avoidants are more likely to have an ambivalent approach to relationships, seeking closeness but also pushing it away out of fear. Their behavior can be unpredictable and inconsistent.

‍

Building Greater Emotional Awareness

Both Dismissive Avoidant and Fearful Avoidant attachment styles are rooted in early experiences that shape the way individuals relate to others. While they share a tendency to avoid emotional closeness, their motivations and behaviors are quite different. Dismissive Avoidants are primarily driven by a desire for independence and self-sufficiency, while Fearful Avoidants experience a deep internal conflict between wanting intimacy and fearing rejection.

Understanding these attachment styles can help individuals navigate their relationships and foster greater emotional awareness. By recognizing and addressing these patterns, it’s possible to build more secure and fulfilling relationships, even for those with avoidant tendencies.

‍

Grouport Offers All Kinds of Therapy Options

Grouport Therapy provides online group therapy, individual therapy, couples therapy, family therapy, intensive outpatient program, teen therapy, and a DBT-Self Guided Program. All our sessions are therapist-led, held virtually, and meet over video chat at the same time each week. All our sessions are therapist-led and are held virtually and meet over video chat at the same time each week. For group therapy, we have groups on many topics including Dialectical Behavior Therapy "DBT", Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, Anxiety & Depression, Trauma & PTSD, Anger Management, OCD, Borderline Personality Disorder, Bipolar Disorder, Relationship Issues, Divorce, Narcissistic Abuse, Self-Compassion, Grief & Loss, Parenting, Substance Abuse, Supporting A Loved one with BPD, among others. Each group is led by a licensed therapist that typically has over a decade of experience treating a wide range of specialties, and the group meets at the same time each week for an hour with the same members and therapist.
‍

As reported by our members, 70% experienced significant progress within 8 weeks, including reduced anxiety & depression symptoms.
‍

Our care coordinators can help assist you to craft the perfect treatment plan for you that's tailored to your needs. We provide speedy matches to quality care, and also provide the flexibility to switch your therapist or group at anytime ensuring that you're always meeting with the right therapist fit at a time that's convenient for your schedule. Whatever type of therapy you’re seeking, Grouport offers a range of options to suit your schedule and preferences. Explore our programs to find the support you need. If you need help finding the right type of therapy, schedule a free call with a care coordinator here.