Essential Questions in Discernment Counseling: A Guide to Navigating Relationship Uncertainty

Relationships are complex, and sometimes couples find themselves at a crossroads where they are uncertain about whether to stay together or separate. In such times, discerning the best path forward can feel overwhelming. Discernment counseling is a specialized type of therapy designed to help couples who are uncertain about the future of their relationship. It provides a structured space to explore whether to attempt to repair the relationship or move toward separation with clarity.

If you find yourself considering discernment counseling, it's important to know that the process involves asking deep, meaningful questions that help uncover underlying issues and facilitate decision-making. In this article, we'll explore some essential discernment counseling questions that can guide couples through this critical process.

‍

What Is Discernment Counseling?

Before diving into specific questions, it's helpful to understand what discernment counseling is and how it works. Discernment counseling is typically short-term—often just a few sessions—and focuses on helping couples decide whether they want to work on their relationship or proceed with divorce or separation. Unlike traditional couples counseling, which seeks to fix the relationship, discernment counseling is focused on decision-making and clarifying the future.

In discernment counseling, both partners participate in discussions guided by a trained therapist, but each partner has the option to make a choice about the next steps independently. The goal is to gain clarity on whether both parties are willing to commit to couples therapy or if it's time to part ways.

‍

Key Questions in Discernment Counseling

The core of discernment counseling lies in asking thoughtful questions that lead to self-awareness, honest reflection, and better understanding between partners. Below are some of the most essential questions asked during the process:

‍

1. What Are the Core Issues in Your Relationship?

This question helps identify the root causes of conflict or dissatisfaction in the relationship. It’s important to reflect on what is truly driving the uncertainty—whether it's communication issues, infidelity, differing values, or unmet emotional needs. Often, couples may have surface-level issues that mask deeper, more fundamental problems.

2. What Are You Hoping to Achieve in This Process?

Discernment counseling is about clarity, not necessarily reconciliation. Asking each partner what they hope to gain from counseling can help reveal their personal goals and expectations. Are they seeking to save the relationship, or are they simply exploring options before deciding on separation? This helps both partners gauge whether they are on the same page or if one person is more committed to the idea of staying together than the other.

3. What Are Your Fears About the Future of the Relationship?

Fear can be a powerful motivator, and it’s essential to explore what each partner is afraid of in the context of the relationship. Do they fear the pain of breaking up, the impact on children, or loneliness after a divorce? Addressing fears head-on helps clear away some of the emotional fog and can guide both partners toward making informed decisions.

4. How Committed Are You to Making This Relationship Work?

Commitment is central to the success of any relationship, especially in times of uncertainty. This question invites each person to assess their level of dedication to improving the relationship. Are both partners willing to put in the effort required to repair the relationship, or is one person already emotionally checked out? The answer can shed light on whether reconciliation is a viable option.

5. What Would It Take for You to Stay in This Relationship?

This question invites both partners to articulate what changes or improvements would need to happen for them to feel motivated to stay together. It can uncover unmet needs, desires, and concerns that might not have been discussed before. For example, one partner might want more emotional intimacy, while the other may need more space or time to feel heard. Understanding these needs can help clarify whether the relationship is salvageable.

6. What Would It Look Like if You Were to Separate?

Exploring the possibility of separation allows each partner to reflect on the consequences and logistics of ending the relationship. This question often prompts individuals to think about life post-separation and what that might look like for them personally, financially, and socially. Sometimes, just visualizing a life apart can bring clarity or help uncover unresolved emotional attachments that may influence the decision-making process.

7. What Are the Strengths of Your Relationship?

While it’s easy to focus on the problems and difficulties in a relationship, it's equally important to reflect on its strengths. What brought you together in the first place? What do you value about your partner and your life together? Recognizing the positive aspects of the relationship can provide hope and motivation to work through the challenges, or it can help both partners see if those strengths are enough to overcome the difficulties they face.

8. How Will You Feel if You Decide to Stay Together or Part Ways?

Emotional reflection is key to discernment counseling. This question helps each person envision the emotional outcome of both staying together and separating. It allows individuals to assess their comfort levels with both options and reflect on the emotional costs of each choice. This self-awareness can help guide the decision toward the best course of action.

9. Are You Willing to Do the Work Required for Reconciliation?

If both partners are leaning toward staying together, it’s crucial to assess their willingness to invest in couples therapy or other forms of relationship repair. Are they ready to address difficult topics, change harmful patterns, and rebuild trust? If one or both partners are not ready or willing to do this work, it could indicate that separation might be a more realistic choice.

10. What Do You Want Your Life to Look Like Moving Forward, Regardless of the Outcome?

This forward-looking question encourages both partners to think beyond the immediate relationship crisis and reflect on their long-term goals. Whether together or apart, what kind of life do they envision for themselves? This question can help individuals better understand their own needs, values, and desires and how they align with the future of the relationship.

‍

Moving Toward Healing

Discernment counseling is a powerful tool for couples who are uncertain about the future of their relationship. The questions explored in this article are designed to guide individuals through the complex emotions and decisions that come with relationship uncertainty. By engaging in this reflective process, couples can gain clarity, make more informed decisions, and move forward with confidence, whether that means working to rebuild the relationship or deciding to part ways.

If you’re in a relationship where you're facing significant uncertainty, consider seeking out a qualified discernment counselor to guide you through the process. The questions discussed here are just a starting point, and the right counselor can tailor the process to fit your unique relationship dynamics. Whatever decision you make, remember that clarity and self-awareness are key to creating a future that aligns with your values and emotional needs.

‍

Grouport Offers All Kinds of Therapy Options

Grouport Therapy provides online group therapy, individual therapy, couples therapy, family therapy, intensive outpatient program, teen therapy, and a DBT-Self Guided Program. All our sessions are therapist-led, held virtually, and meet over video chat at the same time each week. All our sessions are therapist-led and are held virtually and meet over video chat at the same time each week. For group therapy, we have groups on many topics including Dialectical Behavior Therapy "DBT", Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, Anxiety & Depression, Trauma & PTSD, Anger Management, OCD, Borderline Personality Disorder, Bipolar Disorder, Relationship Issues, Divorce, Narcissistic Abuse, Self-Compassion, Grief & Loss, Parenting, Substance Abuse, Supporting A Loved one with BPD, among others. Each group is led by a licensed therapist that typically has over a decade of experience treating a wide range of specialties, and the group meets at the same time each week for an hour with the same members and therapist.
‍

As reported by our members, 70% experienced significant progress within 8 weeks, including reduced anxiety & depression symptoms.
‍

Our care coordinators can help assist you to craft the perfect treatment plan for you that's tailored to your needs. We provide speedy matches to quality care, and also provide the flexibility to switch your therapist or group at anytime ensuring that you're always meeting with the right therapist fit at a time that's convenient for your schedule. Whatever type of therapy you’re seeking, Grouport offers a range of options to suit your schedule and preferences. Explore our programs to find the support you need. If you need help finding the right type of therapy, schedule a free call with a care coordinator here.